A steel price far below the market is the most common bait in advance-payment fraud. How the scam works, real cases, and how to check a seller before you pay.
Short answer: if a price is well below what other suppliers quote for the same grade, size, quantity and delivery terms, treat it as a warning until proven otherwise. Check that the seller is a real, registered company, and do not pay the full amount upfront to an account you have not verified.
How the scam works
- The bait. A listing, email or chat offers steel well below the market, with stock "ready to ship" and fast delivery.
- The pressure. "Price valid until Friday", "only two containers left". The aim is to make you pay before you check.
- The payment. A large deposit or the full amount by bank transfer, sometimes to an account in another name or another country.
- The fees. After the first payment, new costs appear: an export licence, insurance, inspection, port charges. Each one is "the last".
- The silence. Nothing ships, or only part of it, and the seller stops answering or reappears under a new name.
Real cases
- Paid for scrap metal, received concrete (New York, 2019). Shell companies set up "ostensibly" to sell scrap metal to buyers in the US and abroad took payment and did not deliver. Later, buyers who had ordered copper and other scrap were sent concrete and road barriers instead. A New York lawyer who pleaded guilty in the scheme was sentenced to four years in prison and ordered to pay US$500,000 in restitution; the fraudulent sales came to more than US$500,000.
- "Below market prices", then fee after fee. The US Embassy in Sierra Leone lists the "sale of minerals, such as gold or diamonds, at below market prices" among common scams, backed by "many forged official looking documents". It warns that "any number of fees are requested for processing the transaction with each fee purported to be the last required."
- The scale. In 2025 the FBI's Internet Crime Complaint Center received 56,478 complaints of non-payment or non-delivery, with reported losses of US$503,373,587, and 7,762 advance-fee complaints with losses of US$155,910,852. These are complaints filed in the United States, and the non-delivery category also counts sellers who were never paid.
None of these sellers needed real goods. They needed the money before the buyer could check.
Why the price gives it away
Steel is a traded commodity. Producers and traders buy similar raw materials and work on thin margins, so a deep discount on a standard product usually means one of three things: the seller does not have the goods, the goods are not what is described, or the seller does not intend to deliver.
Get several quotes for exactly the same grade, size, quantity and delivery terms before you judge a price.
Warning signs
- A price well below other quotes for the same specification and terms.
- Full payment, or a large deposit, before any inspection.
- A bank account in another company's name, a person's name, or a third country.
- New fees after you have paid.
- A website registered a few weeks ago, no address you can verify, or contact only through chat apps.
- No video call from the warehouse, no inspector you choose, no letter of credit.
How to protect yourself
- Check the company yourself. Look it up in the official business registry of its country (in China, the National Enterprise Credit Information Publicity System at gsxt.gov.cn) and check that the bank account holder is the same company as the one on your contract.
- Use payment terms that protect you. The US International Trade Administration puts it plainly: "For importers, any payment is a donation until the goods are received." A letter of credit "protects the buyer since no payment obligation arises until the goods have been shipped as promised." Or pay a small deposit, with the balance against an inspection report and the shipping documents.
- Inspect before you pay the balance, with an inspector you choose.
- Confirm by phone or video on contact details you found yourself, not ones in the offer.
- If you have already paid, move fast. Ask your bank to recall the transfer and report it to the police the same day.
How SinoAli handles it
Your contract is with a registered Chinese company, and you choose who inspects. We can help clarify specifications, check documents, coordinate inspection and arrange dispatch steps. Any product on sinoali.com can be bought through a SinoAli contract.
Sources
- U.S. Attorney's Office, Eastern District of New York, Staten Island Attorney Richard Luthmann Sentenced to Four Years in Prison for Fraud and Extortion Conspiracies, 9 September 2019
- U.S. Embassy in Sierra Leone, Financial Scams, 28 March 2024
- FBI Internet Crime Complaint Center, 2025 IC3 Annual Report, April 2026
- U.S. International Trade Administration, Methods of Payment